The record is designed to assist individuals from abroad fill vacant jobs on decrease visa charges and permits their employers to pay them 80% of the position’s normal fee, all the way down to a minimal of £20,960.
The MAC has beforehand stated that this low cost ought to be scrapped to forestall the undercutting of resident employees and the exploitation of migrants.
If ministers accepted this key suggestion, the committee stated, it could imply many of the roles presently on the record are not eligible as they might obtain solely a “negligible benefit” by being included.
The proposed change would go away principally low-wage occupations eligible for the record, which the committee stated raised “several concerns”.
Low-paid roles usually tend to see migrants exploited and can extra seemingly result in a internet fiscal value for the UK, that means a number of the burden may fall to the taxpayer, the MAC stated.
Women are extra seemingly than males to be paid under the going fee the place that’s an choice, the committee stated, suggesting some discrimination could have taken place.
The committee stated it was not satisfied the record supplies a “sensible immigration solution” to labour shortages and advisable the Government abolish it.
Instead, the MAC recommended it could possibly be commissioned to hold out standalone opinions of the position of immigration in sure sectors, resembling manufacturing or hospitality.
The committee did suggest eight occupations for the 2023 UK-wide record – together with care employees, lab technicians, bricklayers, roofers and animal care providers – however stated “going forward” the scheme ought to be scrapped.
For the Scotland-only record, it recommended fishing and forestry managers and boat and ship builders be included.
Home Secretary Suella Braverman , who is anticipated to talk on the Tory Party convention later, was despatched a duplicate of the report on Tuesday morning.
Business chiefs have beforehand backed the SOL, calling for a extra liberalised method to immigration to spice up financial progress.
But immigration minister Robert Jenrick has stated employers ought to look to the home workforce moderately than searching for “lower-skilled labour” from abroad, with figures displaying internet migration hit a report excessive final 12 months.
Committee chairman Professor Brian Bell stated: “Our review recommends a total of 10 occupations be placed on the shortage occupation list. Going forward, however, we think that the Government should work to abolish the SOL.
“The SOL has always played a relatively minor role in immigration policy, but recent changes to the immigration system have diminished that role further.
“We are not convinced that the SOL is an effective tool to address labour shortages across different occupations and sectors.
“We think a broader approach that focuses on all aspects of the labour market for a particular sector, of which immigration may be part, would be more beneficial.”
Focusing on recruiting domestically and serving to to return a few of those that turned inactive through the pandemic would require employers to be extra modern, Prof Bell stated.
“I don’t personally think there’s anything wrong with firms having to work a bit harder to get workers.”
The Government has been contacted for remark.
